Does the feedback you receive from colleagues and friends often just feels like criticism? Like you can’t do anything right? Then you are probably experiencing the psychological phenomenon of reactance. This unpleasant arousal occurs when you feel your freedom is being limited. In this blog I will explain how reactance works and what you can do to reduce it in yourself and others. By reducing reactance you will be more capable of accepting valuable feedback and grow as a result.
– How to use the insights from behavioral science to improve your health and wellbeing –
Reading time: 6 minutes
Since the new rules for reducing the Coronavirus have been announced in The Netherlands on 13 October, we can no longer play squash matches. So we do training routines at 1,5m distance and we give each other feedback to improve. But when my friend tells me how to improve my squash skills, it feels like criticism. He tells me I should look at the ball when I hit it, but I’m sure I was doing just that (until we looked at the video recording of our training session). And also, my friend does not look at the ball either, when he plays it, so how can he coach me on how to do it? He says that the fact that he does not look at the ball either, is exactly the reason why he can spot the same behavior when watching me. Yeah, right! All these reactions that I experience – and we all do from time to time – are forms of reactance.
When you experience reactance
- You may experience this in personal situations with your spouse, when (s)he provides you with “tips” on how to improve your appearance for a business meeting or gives you feedback on how to change your tone of voice when in an argument.
- You may experience this in a training context, where trainers provide you with points you can improve on skills that you have used for years. If you have been involved in training to improve you interpersonal skills, you know what I’m talking about: you are provided with feedback on what to start doing, what to stop doing and what to keep doing.
- You may also experience this in a business context when receiving feedback from your colleague or manager on your last project; it is easy to criticize the way of working from the sideline. You may sometimes think: “If you know so well how to do it, why didn’t you do it yourself!”
- Or you may even have experienced this when your government announced the latest measures to control the Coronavirus.
People do not like it when their freedom it threatened
Feedback is a powerful tool to improve our behavior so we can keep on growing. It also requires that we let others influence our behavior. Most of the times this is obviously in our own interest. We can choose whether to embrace the feedback or not. Often, we react negatively to these influence attempts in more or less explicit ways. This is what professor Jack W. Brehm calls psychological reactance. Reactance occurs when a person feels that someone or something is taking away their choices or limiting the range of alternatives. When that specific behavior is limited, than you will find that specific behavior more attractive. Next, you will most likely try to restore your freedom in performing that behavior.
For example, when your spouse provides you with “tips” on how to change your tone of voice when in an argument, you may feel that you are restricted in they way you talk (your freedom to choose your own behavior is threatened). This may make you more likely to continue using that tone (this behavior becomes more attractive). Next, you may say something “I will decide for myself what tone I will use!” (attempt to restore your freedom). This behavior will most likely escalate the argument you are having. Your spouse probably had your best interests in mind when providing these tips. However, because of reactance to the feedback, it did escalate.
Romeo and Juliet effect
If you have adolescent children, you may also be familiar with the Romeo and Juliet effect: parental opposition to a relationship intensifies the romantic feelings of those in the relationship. The effect gets its name from the relationship between the protagonists in William Shakespeare’s late 16th-century play, Romeo Montague and Juliet Capulet, whose families were opposed to their union. The teenagers won a lasting union in their tragic act of twin suicide, an ultimate expression of freedom of choices.Romeo and Juliet effect explained Click To Tweet
This is not merely and individual effect. When Florida banned the use of phosphates in laundry detergent in 1972, residents of Miami no longer had the freedom to choose to buy detergents with phosphates (their freedom to choose their own detergent was restricted). As a result, Miami consumers came to see phosphate detergent as better products than before (the detergent with phosphates became more attractive). In attempts to restore their freedom, many people turned to smuggling, sometimes boasting of twenty-year supplies of phosphate detergent. Some drove with neighbors and friends to nearby counties to load up on phosphate detergents (attempts to restore their freedom).
When reactance is enhanced
Furthermore, German-Austrian researchers found that groups of people show reactance when a threat to their freedom originated within their own group, and that they did show reactance when it originated from outside the group. This means that groups of people who believe that phosphates should be banned, would show far less reactance than people who believe that phosphates should not be banned. In the same way more reactance is expected from people who do not agree with the seriousness of the Conora virus compared to people who agree with the seriousness of the Corona virus. The first groups perceived the threat to their freedom to originate from outside their own group. This will likely lead to increased reactance towards the new rules for reducing the Coronavirus.
Become a feedback Buddha
So what can you do about reactance? I don’t know anyone who does not experience reactance. Some people experience it more than others. So how can you move towards the group, who experiences less reactance? There are two ways to become more like the Buddha:
1. Focus on feelings of threat
Reactance occurs when a person feels that their freedom is limited. So the first step is to focus on feelings of threat. If you are the one receiving the feedback, take a step back to ponder about your feelings. Perhaps the feedback makes you feel bad. It would probably be helpful to acknowledge for yourself that this feedback makes you feel bad.
On top of that, you could share this with the person giving you feedback. Ponder for a moment, whether the person giving you feedback has your best interests at heart. If you believe that, then you probably should share your feelings with that person. If you are in doubt, you should probably share as well. This will make it more likely that you will use other peoples’ feedback to grow their abilities and skills.
If you are the one providing the feedback, don’t give the facts, but focus on anticipated loss of freedom. Acknowledge that there may be limitations in the range of alternative behaviors for that group. This will make it more likely that other people will use your feedback to grow their abilities and skills.
In managing reactance for larger groups, it will be helpful to persuade people to see the desired behavior as an act of solidarity for everybody instead of forced conformity of a selected group. For example, in accepting phosphate free detergents, campaigns could focus on acknowledging that we collectively have to give up some choices for a better world for all of us, including our children and grand-children. This will make it more likely that groups of people will use your feedback to grow their abilities and skills.
2. Restore freedom of choice
As said, reactance occurs when a person feels that their freedom is limited. Thus, the second step is to focus on limitations of freedom. You can do this by giving people a choice to accept or reject the proposed behavior.
So next time you are giving feedback to your colleague, provide them with the feedback and add: “…, but you are free to accept or reject my suggestions.” This will most likely restore their freedom of choice (which they always had to begin with).
You can also ask this of others when you are the one receiving feedback. You can even add this at the end of the feedback session to enhance the chance that you will embrace the feedback by saying: “I suppose I am free to accept or reject your suggestions?” This will most likely restore your freedom of choice as well, although you always had that choice to begin with.
So last time my friend gave me some tips on the squash court, I asked exactly that. He answered: “Well, of course, YOU ultimately decide which tips to accept and which to reject.” It felt a lot easier to follow up his tips from that moment on.Become a Feedback Buddha Click To Tweet
About the author
Niels Vink (1975) is a behavioral economist and sports enthusiast. He has Master degrees in Social Psychology (Leiden University) and Industrial Design Engineering (Delft University of Technology) and holds a PhD in Consumer Behavior. He lives and works (out) in Haarlem.
Want to know how you can get your marketing, communication and sales in better shape? Drop an email at email@example.com
Source of top image: Tim Gouw
SUBSCRIBE TO OUR BLOG